Showing posts with label New System New Face. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New System New Face. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 8, 2026

New System, New Face: Giving A Child Crippling Anxiety With The One Ring Roleplaying Game 2E

The One Ring has been on my radar for years, but I never really bothered to learn any part of the system until recently. This is because I'm a hack and a fraud, and learning new stuff scares me. I also greatly overestimated how important it was to have a physical copy of the game's proprietary symbol-and-tengwar dice in front of you.

Turns out both clauses were (mostly) untrue, so let's dive in shall we?

The Game Itself

TOR is a d12 + xd6 roll-over system in which you perform tasks by trying to beat a target number (usually 14, can go higher or lower) by rolling the Feat die. That's the d12 with Sauron and Gandalf runes for 11 and 12 respectively. To this you add a number of Success dice (d6 with a thinly outlined 1-3, bolded 4 and 5, and a 6 accompanied by the Tengwar letter Lambë, which means "tongue" for some reason) equal to your number of ranks in the skill being used. It's pretty simple, and beneath all the fancy presentation, generic sets of dice are perfectly usable.

TOR is set in the Third Age of jurt's Middle-Earth, although the exact time and place differs between editions. The 1st edition released by Cubicle 7 approximately five hundred years ago back in 2011 is set in Rhovanion in between the events of The Hobbit and The Fellowship. The 2nd edition published by Fria Ligans AKA Free League Publishing in 2020 is set back west in Eriador in the Third Age 2965, a year that had nothing canonical going for it other than the birth of Samwise's older brother Hamson.

The editions differ in a few ways that are mostly minor, meaning that the majority of the content published for one edition can be used for the other with a little bit of fiddling. Which is perfect for me, because as soon as I started to explore the game in earnest I wanted to use the setting and supplements for 1E combined with the mechanics and options of 2E.

Mixing & Matching

I settled on 2E because it had solo rules called Strider Mode written for it a few years ago, and I've been slowly pushing myself to explore that avenue of gaming for a while. But the character I wanted to make would have to be located in Rhovanion, so I took the liberty of ransacking several 1E books to build up the lore and backstory.

The 1E sourcebook The Heart of the Wild details much of Mirkwood and the Vales of Anduin and their inhabitants, including a people of mixed Northmen and Easterling heritage called the Erringmen. Though descended from the Balchoth who once warred with Gondor at the Dark Lord's behest, they've largely given up their past ways and live in peace with their Woodmen neighbors as they meander back and forth through the Vales, herding oxen and generally living as pastoral nomads.

The Erringmen, as inventions of TOR, are less yikes than the depictions of other Easterlings from jurt's canon, although they aren't without one or two problematic implications in this book that I'd be remiss not to touch on. For example, an Erringman NPC named Valderic (they seem to favor the same Gothic-inspired names as the Northmen) is "strong" in his Easterling heritage, being squat, wide, and of sallow complexion.

Being coded with east Eurasian features wouldn't be a problem by itself, except he's also the one named Erringman singled out as reverting to the forbidden old ways; hanging trophy skulls from his war-chariot, dabbling in witchcraft, and even visiting the abandoned ruins of Dol Guldur more than once. Wickedness reasserting itself from deep in someone's family tree is a trope that exists in the Legendarium, but combining that with Valderic's physical traits makes it feel like the kind of negative racial essentialism that TOR generally avoids. (The game embraces "positive" essentialism pretty heavily meanwhile, what with heroic cultures and how closely a character hews to their virtues being one of the primary expressions of character growth and advancement in the game.)

That all said, I love the Erringmen. They are much more than one shady character writeup. They're shown as resourceful and tough, at home in their new home regardless of the grumbling of their Woodmen neighbors. They provide a fun opportunity to interact with a type of culture you hardly ever see fleshed out in the source material. They raise so many roleplaying and worldbuilding possibilities for Rhovanion and beyond. And, they're the subjects of an illustration in the book that I just find endlessly charming:

Wanderers by merlkir, for like the dozenth time on this blog,
but actually used for its intended subject this time around.

Of course I can't have all the nice things I want, so the Erringmen are purely an NPC culture with no opportunity provided to play as them in the book. Which is fine by me, because that just provides me with the opportunity to get creative.

Jumping ahead to 2E and the digital exclusive Peoples of Wilderland, we get updates to most of the player cultures from the 1st edition who were moved away from when the 2nd moved its focus west to Eriador. Included are the Woodmen of Wilderland, who have lived next to and within Mirkwood for ages despite all the dark and vile things emerging from the forest nowadays. They're slightly insular and unfriendly people as a result, but constant foes of the Shadow.

Perhaps they'd hate to know that their cultural characteristics and virtues are easily bent toward building a character of Erringman ancestry: they're good with axes and bows which both cultures love, they have a virtue to gain a loyal hunting dog, they're doughty warriors skilled at skirmish tactics, and they have ranks in Explore, Hunting, and other things the Erringmen likely also rely upon as they travel the Anduin.

Shortly before having this idea I had been reading a list of leaders of the Hunnic empire on Wikipedia. You know, like a normal person does. And I was struck by how many of them have Latinized or Germanicized names by which they're known in most European sources, while their original Hunnic names are little-attested or only guessed at via linguistic reconstruction. This too, I folded into my little homebrew here alongside the nomads and standoffish neighbors.

I didn't use it at all below because by the time I found it I'd already gotten going, but if you're the type who enjoys lifepath generators, they released one of those in this same line of e-books.

The Character Concept, Finally

Soon I hatched the idea of a Woodman and an Erringwoman who met for what was supposed to be a solitary and surreptitious fling one night when her clan encamped outside his village beneath the eaves of Mirkwood so their peoples could trade and share news. It didn't work out that way however, so when the woman's clan rolled back into the clearing before the forest a year later, the Woodman was very surprised to find his brief flame holding their son.

Thus was born Balambyr, as his mother named him, or Balamer as his father's people chose to render it.

Until he weaned he stayed with his mother, but as soon as he could bear to be away, his two families divided his time between them according to the migratory pattern of the Erringmen. He wintered in his father's cabin (for he was forced out of his family's lodge by the scandal of his unmarried dalliance with an outsider), and summered in his mother's wain, which could be anywhere from the western bank of the Celduin to the near side of Rhûn, depending.

It wasn't easy growing up split between two worlds like this. Though his father's family insisted he acknowledge and care for his son (which he probably would have done regardless), no love was lost between them and Balamer the Bastard, as he was sometimes called by Woodmen when they thought him out of earshot. His mother's kin were more accepting but far more demanding, expecting him to pull his weight every migration and thinking him soft for the the six months he spent "just sitting around" each year.

But he survived, even if he did not thrive. From his father he learned forestry and woodworking, and from his mother herding and pathfinding. Both peoples favored the long-hafted axe and the bow, so Balambyr received training in both year-round. They were also the occasion for the few, fond moments where both his parents were together with him in the spring and autumn.

His thirteenth birthday saw him gifted the runt of a litter, much like himself, whom he named Tomyr- or Tom, depending on where they happened to be at the moment. They bonded quickly, and before long were seen everywhere together. And together they stayed safe, as darkness began to billow once again out of the depths of Mirkwood like a cloud.

It didn't come as a surprise when, at the portentous age of sixteen years, a certain glint entered Balambyr's eyes. The reluctant acceptance of his mother's people was gradually won through year after year of hard nomadizing, but he was still desperate to prove himself to the Woodmen at large, or else prove to himself that he was better than all their misgivings. So with a heavy heart and his mother's begrudging blessings, Balambyr's father took him deep into a part of the forest he had never ventured before.

There, in a little village named Rhos, he was introduced to an odd old bearded fellow in a brown robe who often patronized the exploits of the young and daring folk of Wilderland.

Basic Stats

Strider Mode mostly changes how the flow of gameplay works in order to make things less insurmountable for a single character, but it also modifies the character creation process somewhat.

The first step is unchanged: choose your character's Heroic Culture and a set of attributes to use. Since I'm using the Woodmen of Wilderland as a base for Balambyr I picked them and went with the safe, boring choice of 4 Strength (might, dexterity, physical presence), 5 Heart (emotional intelligence, empathy, passion), and 5 Wits (cleverness, attention, ingenuity).

Because I picked Woodmen, Balambyr also gets their Cultural Blessing, a passive ability every member of that culture gets as a baseline. For Woodmen, it's Wood-Goer, the ability to add +2 to Parry rating while fighting in forested environments. It's more circumstantial than I would like, but not bad for someone likely to skulk around Mirkwood for a few adventures.

More juicy than that is my choice of 1 Favoured skill. Favoured skills basically give you advantage, letting you keep the better of 2 Feat dice rolls. Woodmen favor Hunting and Healing, so I went with Healing. Losing a monster's tracks is bad, but failing to staunch a bleeding wound is just death.

Next I subtract my attribute scores from 20 to get the Target Number for each. This is the default difficulty I have beat for most rolls in the game. 16, 15, and 15 aren't the easiest numbers to beat, but there will be ways around that in the future.

From the attribute scores I also derive Endurance, Hope, and Parry; basically hit points, a pool of points to spend to overcome one's limits, and the number enemies need to beat to hit the PC in combat.

Spending Experience

The next step is the first real opportunity for characterization and player choice, because I get to spend 15 (10 in the non-solo base game) experience points from previous adventures on skill and combat proficiency ranks. I left the default axe and bow ranks from Woodmen alone, and spent my points on skills to improve the skills not boosted by Woodmen background, especially putting 3 ranks in Travel to make those long, solitary journeys a little less dangerous.

I ended up with at least 1 rank in everything, because the prospect of solo play amplifies my fear that if I don't bring at least a little bit of everything to the table I will be punished for it; it's like jack of all trades, but the universe is probing me for weaknesses. But Balambyr is still decidedly an outdoorsy type with good starting ranks in Awareness, Hunting, Explore, etc.

Distinctive Features

Balambyr's Distinctive Features come next. Distinctive Features are major aspects of a character's personality or bearing, used to aid roleplaying and inform how they might go about a given situation. They can also be used mechanically, by making a roll Inspired if one of a character's Features is particularly useful for a skill check.

Inspired rolls gain +2d6 instead of +1d6 for every point of Hope you choose to spend, which can be huge if you're in a pinch.

Of course, Strider Mode players get the Strider feature by default, which makes all of your skill rolls Inspired by virtue of their lonesome self-reliance and grit, so the 2 features I chose to give Balambyr came down to roleplaying entirely. He is both True-Hearted for his sometimes inconvenient sincerity, and Wary because a childhood spent without a meaningful sense of belonging in every-shifting circumstances has given him anxious hypervigilance superpowers.

Calling

After that comes Calling, which you could compare to character background packages in other games. These are your Captains, Champions, Scholars, and Treasure Hunters, among other professions that lend themselves well to creating adventurers.

I dithered about on this for a while because I couldn't decide between Messenger and Warden. I honestly might have preferred going with the 1E Wanderer calling instead because it's thematically more appropriate to Balambyr's background of travel. Obviously nomadism ≠ itineracy or romanticized ideas of vagrancy in real life, but in a fantasy game I take what I can get.

Ultimately I fell on the side of Messenger because it inherited most of the Wanderer's mechanics, even if they've been reoriented around an implicitly interpersonal role, acting as ambassador and uniter of far-flung communities. Also because the more I think about it, Wardens and the Rangers they're modeled on just feel a little too much like vigilante border patrol agents and nooo thank you.

Messenger gives me another choice of Favoured skills, which ended up being Courtesy and Travel. I don't see Balambyr actually being all that magnetic in terms of personality, he's just very attentively polite and patient with strangers.

Balambyr also gets a new feature from Messenger: Folk-Lore. His travels have furnished him with knowledge of a scattered assortment of local customs, beliefs, languages, and other things that help him get along wherever he finds himself. This feels very appropriate for Balambyr's time with the Erringmen. Who knows how many other communities besides his father's they pass by each year on their long arc from east to west?

One's Calling also comes with a downside, however. Each has a unique Shadow Path, the shape and texture of a character's corruption which plays out in the event that the Shadow overtakes them and twists their ideals or amplifies unhealthy and harmful traits.

For Balambyr this would be Wandering-Madness: a self-destructive wanderlust that leaves one bereft of home and belonging as they lose the ability to put down roots and form the connections necessary to want to defend the good things of the world. Travel stops being a joy or even a means, and becomes a ruinous coping mechanism. Always moving, never resting, chained to a road that goes ever on and on.

So basically he gets Avoidant Personality Disorder with a side of Dromomania if I fail too many saving throws.

I swear, I was trying to be lighthearted when I started this one.

Gear

Our poor Bastard isn't going to face the winding road all alone and illequipped, at least.

Starting adventurers get a selection of war gear and trinkets to choose from, including 1 weapon in each proficiency they have a rating in, as well as your choice of armor, limited by your character's starting social class.

Naturally Balambyr takes a short bow and a long-hafted axe with him. I also picked up a leather corslet for him, because it's the heaviest "light" armor available, it's the fanciest his social class can afford, and I just really like saying the word "corslet". It's one of those armor words you don't read all that often nowadays, mostly displaced by close-enough terms like hauberk or cuirass. I think the last time I saw it was during one of my brief stints trying to read the original Conan short stories?

Anyway, mercifully for Balambyr's back and his bookkeeping, all mundane items of travel are presumed to be accounted for in TOR, so no need to keep track of nor weigh individual sets of clothing, packs, rations, etc.

The last thing to note is my choice of Useful Item. Useful Items add +1d to noncombat checks with their designated skill as determined upon item acquisition, like a hunting knife for +1d Hunting, or a soothing balm for +1d Healing. There's no real limit to what you pick so long as it's a thing that can be possessed and potentially lost.

Balambyr has a lot of options to choose from for useful items if I draw upon his background. It could be the whittling knife his father gave him, or the thumb ring he received when he started practicing archery. It could be a really nice pair of boots he was gifted before going off to meet his mysterious patron. But since I don't see any prohibitions against useful items being living things, I decided to make it Tomyr. She's not an accomplished hunting hound just yet (I can add that utility to her later on in Balamyr's adventuring career), but her nose has helped keep her two-legged companion on the right trail more than once, so I figure she's worth +1d Travel.

Adventurers technically also start with mounts, but only if they're from backgrounds of Common or higher standard of living, so no pony for our Frugal woodboy.

Finally, each adventurer gets a starting Reward and Virtue from a modest pool of each. Rewards and virtues are your main forms of character advancement in the game, representing gifts granted to you by your friends and allies among the Free Peoples and your own personal growth and ability, respectively.

I had no idea what reward to pick so I went with making my corslet of Cunning Make, which reduced the armor's Load rating by 2 to make for lighter travel. I also bent to the urge to generalize once again and picked Prowess as my virtue, reducing Balambyr's Strength Target Number by 1 to give him flat 15s across the board.

The Sheet

And that's a wrap. Unless I made any grave errors, my sheet is complete. Or it will be once I put everything in a nice form-fillable PDF. Fortunately I happened upon this dang pretty one when I started this post way too many months ago. Its small space for rewards and virtues leaves something to be desired for any but the greenest of adventurers, but the style goes a long way toward making up for it.


The Future

One flaw in pretty much all of my New System, New Face posts up to this point that I've noticed has been that they just peter out after the sheet's done and I don't close it with anything especially noteworthy other than a recap of my feelings toward the system. I think my writing all this shows I'm into TOR, so I figured I'll keep the focus on Balambyr and imagine a bit of a future for him instead.

There's no shortage of danger around Mirkwood for Radagast to send him to deal with or keep tabs on, so I suspect that will occupy him for the first year or two of his career. In that time, with luck, he may strengthen his relationship with the woodmen in general, and his father in particular. But if they fail to fully appreciate him, so be it; he'll learn his worth. From there he may begin to travel farther afield as the situation calls for it, perhaps running into fellow adventurers along the way, perhaps not.

Balambyr's second virtue will be the Hound of Mirkwood cultural virtue for woodmen, so that he and Tomyr can properly adventure together at last. I'll just have a very hard time allowing myself to use the option where Tomyr can take a wound instead of him.

(Don't worry, The Dog Doesn't Die! The rules stipulate that you can bring them back next session with a successful Heal, or after the next Adventuring Phase otherwise.)

Ultimately, the shadowy eaves of Mirkwood will prove to have been shelter for Balambyr rather than a prison. For when he has proven himself capable and steadfast of heart, Radagast will charge him with a mission he would grant to no other, for no one else in his employ has ever seen the places he once visited yearly. The old man would very much like to hear news from a pair of friends he has not spoken to in a very long time.

The next time Balambyr joins his mother's caravan into the east (a journey already fraught with danger as Darkness expands its reach), he must keep an eye out for a pair of equally strange fellows in blue...

The Blue Wizards by TurnerMohan

Monday, March 10, 2025

New System, New Face: Hastily Reviving a Dead Series with Janky Optional Rules for BFRPG

Been a while since I made a character hereabouts, huh? Figured I'd fix that and shoehorn yet more BFRPG into my blog while I'm at it.

As I've mentioned in the past, the open-source game system BFRPG has tons of fan-made content hosted on its site, from new species and classes, to new subsystems, and in at least one case that I know of, a pretty significant rules conversion mod.

Basic Fantasy Questing by Joe Carruthers changes the game from a mixed OSR title into a hybrid between The RPG Not To Be Named and the "Classic d100 Game" that the supplement references obliquely throughout. For those who don't know what that's referring to, like myself when I started this post, it's the original Basic Role-Playing system by Chaosium released in 1980. It's a generic system similar to GURPS or Savage Worlds in that it supports a wide range of genre fiction that you can flesh out using books in their niche. You might have heard of a few of BRP's little genre splats; they include Call of Cthulhu, Stormbringer, and RuneQuest, among others.*

BFQ works like this: you roll your ability scores and pick a species and class like normal, then convert every ±1 of ability modifier into a ±5% to applicable roll-under d100 rolls, like adding Strength percentage to Melee Attack rolls or Wisdom percentage to Divine Casting. Each class has a main skill that determines their HD, like a fighter's highest weapon skill or a thief's highest thief skill. Class skills start at a 55% base chance to succeed, not including modifiers.

For everything outside of the class's niche, you have a new set of Ability Skills to roll. These skills combine saving throws from the core game with the ability checks for all 6 ability scores that you commonly see elsewhere, and their base % is equal to a character's ability score x2. You roll these to push heavy stuff, shrug off the effects of poison, remember lore, etc.

You might notice there's not really anything to build here, though. What would I be doing other than rolling dice and seeing what I end up with?

Well, fortunately Joe included some optional rules for his already optional ruleset: classless characters.

The classless characters rule nudges BFQ much closer to BRP than to D&D by removing classes and opening all skills up to all characters, albeit at much lower starting values than their specialized fellows enjoy. Which comes up as a bit of an issue later on, but for now let's just figuratively and literally roll with it.

Ability score generation is identical to the base game, which means I spent literally hours rolling arrays in a generator until I got one that felt not too crippled by negative modifiers but also not too good that it seemed like I was blatantly fishing for a strong character. Ultimately I found one that's just average enough to help illustrate a few parts of the system.

With this conveniently middling array, we can calculate our classless adventurer's base skills using the following:

You still select species as part of this system, for which I decided to pull in yet another fan supplement; Monsters as Player Characters by Sidney Parham, Omer Golan-Joel, R. Kevin Smoot, and steveman. I decided to go with hobgoblin, since they're kind of like the humans of the humanoid world in a lot of ways, and a generalist character feels appropriate here. They also have a pretty nice Alertness ability that reduces the chance of being surprised, and +5% bonuses to Listen and Finding/Removing Traps, which is great for someone with free access to thief skills.

Maybe they've actually drifted away from their highly regimented community after failing to find a rank and niche to specialize into? A rather uninspired implementation of the societal misfit trope, I know, but one that at least weds plot and mechanics.

We distribute another 50 points on top of the above base values to finish, so that we have at least 1 skill above 55% and none higher than 70%. After some final bookkeeping we've got our hob:

Art stolen from the hedgewitch chapter of Land of Mist.

As you can see, average base values for classless characters start very low to make up for their much greater versatility. This PC's highest ability score, Strength, only amounts to a base of 26% in melee attack and force, although it's actually slightly higher than this thanks to the +5% from the +1 modifier to Strength which still gets applied to all applicable rolls, for a total of 31%. On the flip side, our friend here ain't gonna be doing much wheeling and dealing with an Influence of 11% (16% base -5% from -1 modifier). At early levels they will probably flail and flounder a lot before they eventually slide into a semi-randomly determined niche of whatever they happen to succeed at by sheer dumb luck.

This is where I come to the biggest houserule I would use for a game of BFQ: reverse the progression system.

Under standard BFQ rules, you mark a skill for improvement once during an adventure when you succeed with it. At the end of the adventure you then roll vs your skill to see if you improve it by 1d3+1 points by succeeding at the roll, or just 1 by failing at it. This is fine for use with the class system because it means each class will naturally excel in the area of their expertise from the base game, such as fighters leveling their attack skill much faster than magic-users from having more and higher chances to succeed at a roll, which compounds after a certain point and makes you all but guaranteed to mark a skill for advancement within the first roll or two of a session, while your less relevant skills fall far behind.

But with the base skill calculations of classless BFQ, most of your skills are going to start off well below 50%. This means improving almost anything other than your 1 or 2 favored skills will be a long slog. And if you're going to specialize like that, why not just stick with classes?

So I propose houseruling it so that you mark for advancement every time you fail a roll instead of succeed. Likewise, when rolling to advance, a failure adds the full 1d3+1 points and success adds only 1.

This way, characters are encouraged to try things outside of their comfort zones, and it's easier to build a generalist if one wants. At the same time, the jacks of all trades will be discouraged from becoming masters of anything by the fact that it's harder to fail rolls at higher levels. Quick, early skill advancement naturally trends downward and slows to a crawl as it nears 100%. This is also closer to the the leveling curve of many OSR games, if that's a plus for you. And depending on the players at your table, it might also just feel better to always be getting something out of an action? Losing that Agility check and faceplanting in the mud's no fun, but now you've learned from that mistake, as that old saying goes.


* Okay, technically RuneQuest came first and then had a genericized version of its ruleset spun off into BRP, but I think it's still accurate to say that RuneQuest is "powered by" BRP so to speak.

Friday, February 3, 2023

New System, New Face: Harping on about HARP

I should finished this post last year when I first built a character for the system. But after I fell off of the series somewhat, and now that most of my memories of the event have faded, I have decided to go back in for a refresher course. I hope this slightly less new system, not as new face is still an entertaining read- and I hope readers are buoyed by the fact that I have a climactic endpoint for this series in sight- just not yet.

Game/Context

High Adventure Roleplaying or HARP is another skill-based d100 system published by Iron Crown Enterprises, because I have a problem and need someone's help weening me off of this newfound drug. It was first published in late 2003, with a revised edition following soon after in 2004 to clean up a number of messy rules. There are two differently flavored rulesets for HARP; Fantasy and Science Fiction, or SF. Naturally, I went with fantasy.

HARP is to ICE's MERP what MERP was to original Rolemaster: the same core system, but considerably more streamlined than the last. HARP more-or-less replaced MERP after ICE lost the license to continue publishing Tolkien material, though I would have liked to see some sort of rework of the latter using the former. Maybe in an alternate timeline somewhere, there's a heartbreaker called MARP.

HARP also took some cues from the d20 system, since D&D 3.5E had just dropped earlier that year and the world was fast-approaching critical spinoff popularity mass. I'm sure there are grognards out there who can articulate the similarities exactly, but this influence was most evident to me in the ability to multiclass, as well as the Talent system, which is like a less limited Feat system from 3E. I also saw it in the way you can acquire a small pool of Fate Points that you can burn to provide bonuses to rolls in emergencies- D&D's Action or Hero Points, essentially.

Other than that, HARP is still very Rolemastery. You create a character from a combination of starting profession, species, childhood experiences, and cultural background. You build them up from there in a loosely guided, very granular manner using the Development Points you're rewarded on level-up. Pretty much everything you do is covered by skills which are in turn grouped under and governed by the eight statistics- Strength, Constitution, Agility, Quickness, Self Discipline, Reasoning, Insight, and Presence.

The HARP core rulebook provides everything you need to play, as well as some implied setting lore, mostly through species and cultures. But for a more explicit campaign setting (and the crunchy rules options that go along with it) we can look to the HARP products detailing Mithra--also called Gryphon World--and its main focus, the continent of Cyradon.

Cyradon

Cyradon is billed as having the key word "fun", according to its own overview and marketing blurbs. While the idea of being marketed as "fun" in detached quotes always manages to get a snicker out of me, I understand what they were getting at. It's meant to be a high fantasy, swashbuckling setting where even low-level characters (whom the first Cyradon book is designed around) can help reshape the world. There's big adventure to be had, and little narrative grimness to muck through despite the world having just survived another major cataclysm.

Humans went extinct on Cyradon long ago, and for centuries it was mostly barren and empty with few, unfriendly nations far apart. But all of that is changing as waves of refugees from other, more on-fire parts of the world arrive en masse through portals to the ruined city of Belynar, which just so happens to be under the care of a small gryphon community.

Mithra is also known as Gryphon World because of the major role that gryphons play in it. They're an ancient and wise people, second only to the dragons that have been around since the birth of the world. In the long background of Mithra, the winged and quadrupedal gryphons cast off enslavement and developed an advanced civilization that pops up time and again. You can actually play a gryphon in-game, helping to guide the newcomers and upstarts in Belynar and beyond.

Gryphons are playable alongside the other species that were either translated wholesale or tweaked and adapted from the base game. These include the brand-new human immigrants to Cyradon, the Sithi (elves), Mablung (dwarves), Rhona (gnomes), Arali (elves again except haughtier), Nagazi (lizardfolk), and the Gryx. You can also play a character of mixed heritage from any combination of the humanoid species above by purchasing Lesser or Greater Blood talents.

The Gryx are nomads who once hailed from the far eastern steppe of the supercontinent Anias. An unknown tragedy drove them from their ancestral home in great, migrating tribes that traveled or settled all across the world. Their attempted genocide at the hands of a xenophobic theocracy led to them being driven away again, and now many Gryx have wound up in Cyradon with all the other global refugees. Their autonym is G'Shul, meaning "the homeless" in their heavily glottal, clicking language of Taloc.

Gryx are basically the setting's stand-in for orcs, though with a far more peaceable temperament than most other turn-of-the-century depictions. They even lack the overtly martial warrior culture that other, more heroic orcs often have, in favor of being private, pastoral, perhaps a little dour, but above all wishing to avoid trouble.

Unfortunately for the Gryx, trouble tends to find them, in part because of their "monstrous" appearance. They are huge and musclebound as a rule, so much so that they have a racial penalty to swimming because of how dense and prone to sinking their bodies are. They are endowed with prominent brows, blotchy skin, tusks, flat noses, and everything else that orcs tend to get depicted with. Many of them also possess forehead ridges of protruding bone, giving them more than a passing resemblance to the Orsimer of later The Elder Scrolls installments, or particularly pointy Klingons.

Every step of the way out of their lost homeland, the G'Shul left totems planted in the ground. Each totem possesses a unique but fierce visage often likened to a monster or demon face by outsiders. They are all erected facing east, toward their ancient homeland. No one knows why they do this and the G'Shul don't speak of such things, but the most popular theory is that they raise them in defiance of whatever evil drove them out- or perhaps as an apotropaic ward to keep it from spreading.

This is 200% my jimmy-jams, so that's what I'm picking.

Streamlined, but not quite Svelte

Instead of MERP's 10-step character creation process that requires you to flip back and forth throughout the book, we get a slightly smoother and more straightforward 6.

  1. Choose a Profession
  2. Generate Statistics
  3. Choose a Race & Culture
  4. Buy Skills & Talents
  5. Purchasing Equipment
  6. Final Touches

There are a lot of professions to choose from in HARP, owing to their relative simplicity. Each profession is essentially a bundle of free skill ranks, a list of relevant skill categories you have to pay less to improve, and one unique ability. For example Fighters get a few free general and athletic skills, a bunch of physical and combat skills, cheaper future purchases in all four of those skill categories, and then finally a bonus to combat skill rolls that scales with level. As with previous skill-focused games, your starting profession does not set a hard limit on how you choose to build and grow your character.

I have been neglecting magic for my entire stay in d100 land thus far, so I think it's finally time to remedy that by picking a spell-caster. That doesn't narrow the list down as much as you might expect, though.

There are 9 professions in the core book, and of them 5 have native spellcasting- Cleric, Harper, Mage, Ranger, and Warrior Mage. Mage gets subdivided into 5 different specialties in the College of Magics supplement; the generalist Magician, Elementalist, Necromancer, Thaumaturge, and Vivamancer. There are also the Adventurer, Mystic, Shadowblade, and Druid presented in The Codex, each of which has a spell sphere. There's a scattering of another half-dozen professions across HARP's other publications, including the Harper's Bazaar series that ran from 2004 to 2008, some of which have been reprinted elsewhere in more official forms. There would be even more to choose from, but I don't have a copy of HARP's dedicated religion book, Beyond the Veil.

Professional Indecision

To help narrow things down, I need to hone my concept a little more. I personally like that a single idea can be mechanically executed in multiple ways, and would rather have that than the opposite problem, though I understand why some might find the redundancy undesirable in a system.

Gryx aren't very prominent magicians or priests in the lore of Mithra- none of the religious or magical orders described in the books are founded by or have a significant Gryx component. Paradoxically, they are noted as being very pious, sometimes superstitious people who venerate many deities- they were even instrumental in revitalizing worship of the so-called Shrine Gods of the Juras Mountains that they just sort of picked up and took with them during their flight from the steppes. The dispersed nature of the gryx tribes probably lends quite a bit of internal diversity and syncretism to their practices, though that's just my reasoning.

What does seem consistent about Gryxian religion across the board is that it is deeply animistic, and many of their gods such as the aforementioned mountain gods might actually be yazatas- powerful nature spirits that gryphon scholars hold to be different from deities. They might technically be correct, but that isn't a great concern for the Gryx who already venerate nature.

The Shaman from HARPer's Bazaar Issue 06 ends up looking like my best choice, as they directly interact with spirits and totems on a regular basis. Shocking for me to pick a shaman, I know. Just go ahead and ignore the time in this same series where I already made an orc shaman. It's totally different this time, I promise.

Now that I've settled on a profession, I need to choose the Mana source for my magic. I also need to choose a couple of Spell Focus Styles- the techniques or gestures you use during casting.

Mana, everybody's favorite misunderstood Polynesian concept, returns in HARP as the power source for all magic. It is latent in pretty much all things in the world, and comes in the flavors of Personal, Ambient, Granted, or Fixed Mana. Personal mana is what you've got in your own body, Ambient mana is plucked right out of the land and air around you, Granted mana is gifted to you by a higher power source like a god, and Fixed mana is sucked out of magically potent spell components like prepared herbs, gems, or animal parts. There's another type called Pure Mana, but that's only accessible around leylines when you're mucking about with big, dangerous High Magic stuff.

Each type of mana tapping has different advantages and disadvantages, and requires a talent to use. Fortunately every new character receives one tap talent for free.

Because I'm picking Shaman, the responsibility of building an entire Gryxian religious order with membership benefits, structure, and dogma is taken out of my hands- as is access to Granted mana, which is the cleric's whole schtick. Personal mana is the most common type of tap in the world, basically amounting to a personal magic bar that you can deplete. It has a secular connotation though, which I don't think fits my Gryx.

I'm left choosing between Ambient and Fixed mana, both of which feel equally valid for an animistic expression of magic. At first I was tempted to go with Fixed mana because my shaman would always try to have plenty of ingredients for traditional alchemy or charmcraft on hand- but then I got to thinking about it and decided that might be too much dependency on finite resources, and so opted to pick Ambient. There are mana-poor areas that make casting harder, but that's a tradeoff I'm more comfortable with than being caught with no means at all, especially at low and money-starved levels.

Now to decide on my two free Spell Focus Styles. Each Spell Focus dictates the way you weave magic sigils. When you use your technique properly, you get a small roll bonus; if you can't use it, you risk massive penalties and even fumbles. Not all magic needs to be cast using Somatic components in HARP, although that absolutely is one option.

Besides Somatic, there are Gestural (only need one hand but you don't get the potential bonus Somatic offers), Song/Music (a la bards and the like), Trance (monkly micro-meditations), Verbal (exactly what it sounds like), and various focus items like wands or a warrior mage's weapon. I will pick Gestural because it is the easiest requirement to meet on the fly, as well as Trance because while it may have been written with martial artists in mind, trances and other altered states of consciousness are often important in shamanic traditions.

And there we have it! Step 1 done in a paltry... 800 words. I promise it'll go quicker than this.

Generating Statistics

There are three ways to generate your 8 main stats: make percentile rolls until every result is at least 40 and assign as you like, use a 550 point-buy system where stat costs start to ramp up at 91, or use a 500 point-buy plus 10d10. After some consideration I decided to go with method 1 and roll everything. I thought it might inject some fun and interesting decisions into what would otherwise be a very safe, evenly spread array.

That's what I thought.

But then I started thinking that my interpretation of the rules-as-written might be a little off. In retrospect, I should have listened to that instinct. "Make 8 percentile rolls until all results are at least 40 or higher" reads to me like I'm supposed to throw the entire set out if a single result is 39 or below. This means each set of 8 has a 0.01917073 probability of being legal. I should have just quit and rolled individually until I had 8 qualifying rolls, but as evidenced by this series and the continued existence of this entire blog, I am committed to my bad ideas.

A few hours later, I finally came up with this:

Perfectly serviceable. Very slightly better on average than if I had taken the 550, and without any negative modifiers besides. Almost boring, in fact.

Unlike the casting professions from the core rulebook, the HARPer's Bazaar zines never actually stated what stats the Shaman uses to cast its spells- my guess is that was a bit of writer/editor oversight. But following convention of classes using a combination of Self Discipline and one other pertinent stat, I've gone ahead and picked Insight for the shaman- in many ways it is like Wisdom in a d20 system.

With that in mind, I will arrange my stats as follows: 50 Strength / 54 Constitution / 62 Agility / 67 Quickness / 95 Self Discipline / 69 Reasoning / 97 Insight / 68 Presence.

Converted into actual modifiers and then added to Gryxian adjustments, that array takes the shape of: +4 St / +4 Co / +3 Ag / +4 Qu / +11 SD / +4 Re / +10 In / +4 Pr.

Presence isn't really listed as an important stat for the Shaman, but I expect I'd want to be at least a little bit diplomatic with spirits or members of my Gryx's tribe whenever possible. Shamans have as much social responsibility as they do spiritual, and often the two are inextricably linked.

A gripe I had with MERP was that after rolling your stats and adjusting for your species modifiers, you pretty much never use the raw numbers ever again except in extremely rare circumstances, making them kind of pointless. I'm pleased to say that issue isn't in HARP, because you can continue to increase your stats (and thus your stat modifiers) throughout your character's career. I still think it's kind of an extra step that could be simplified by cutting them out and only bothering with modifiers, but that's the nature of the system I chose to play with.

A point in the system's favor is that they really streamlined this part in the revised edition of the game. Once upon a time, the number of Development Points (DPs) you'd get with every level-up was dependent upon each of your statistic scores, swinging wildly between zero or minimum point rewards and significant progress depending on how big the numbers are. But you can invest DPs into raising your statistics even higher, therefore getting even more DPs the next time you level up.

This system rewarded a "spiral" of continual reinvestment at the expense of every other dimension of character development, resulting in very boring designs, uneven group dynamics, and in the long-term, characters that have grossly swollen beyond intended game balance. On the other end of the spectrum, was even possible for someone to roll so poorly on character generation that they were incapable of earning DPs!

Nowadays, you get a flat number every level.

I'm glad I only spent a couple of hours spreadsheeting optimal stat cutoff points before I learned about the revised edition.

Race & Culture

Gryx and Nomad. Boom. Next question.

Skills & Talents

Here's another crunchy section. Pretty much the entire game is skill-driven, so this is where my character's rough outline gets sharpened into definition. I have several free skill ranks from my profession and culture, plus 100 DPs to spend at 1st level. Skills in my profession's favored categories (General, Mystical, Outdoors, and Physical) cost 2 points a rank, while everything else costs 4 points. Max ranks in a single skill are calculated using the formula (3 x Level) + 3. At level 1 the maximum is 6; at level 30 it rises to 93.

You can also receive a discount on skill ranks by purchasing a Training Package. Training Packages are almost like prestige classes in a way. Each represents a specialized role or membership in an in-universe organization that your character has to be a member of, or join over the course of a campaign. Each package is a bundle of skills that represent the experience your character has gained from serving that organization or guild.

For example, if you want to be an Arcurias Bowman, you have to be a Sithi elf or descended from one. The package gives you ranks in Armor, Stalk & Hide, Sniping, Bows and one other Weapon Skill for a ~25% discount depending on how the favored categories line up- just the sort of thing a defender of the Sithi homelands needs.

The Gryx of Mithra have a few nice, flavorful packages that I want to shout out, even though I won't be using them yet. The G'Shul Rover is a hunter and scout who keeps the G'Shul tribes and their herds safe and fed during the migrations, while the Osh'Tahl Herbalist is a traditional healer skilled in herblore. My Gryx might pick up Osh'Tahl Herbalist someday to represent his increased attention to alchemy, but for now he's starting with the Traditionalist Mage package.

The Traditionalist Mage is a healer, soothsayer, and/or wise one for isolated settlements and nomadic tribes- perfect for a Gryxian shaman. The package gives 20 ranks in Cantrips, Divination, Healing, Herbcraft, Fauna or Flora Lore, Perception, Power Point (PP) Development, and Spell Casting, with Cantrips/Healing/Spell Casting optionally replaceable for Alchemy and/or Charmcraft. My shaman is going to want literally all of these eventually, so I'll gladly take the early investment now.

As part of the Nomad culture, he also gets free ranks in Animal Handling, Armor, Endurance, Herbcraft, Local Region Lore, Navigation, Perception, Riding, Stalking & Hiding, Swimming, Tracking, and one Missile and one Melee Weapon.

After a lot of tabulation, my final skills look like this:

It helps a lot if you get a spreadsheet for all of this.
You can find one and a few other resources on the ICE forums.

My desire to always have one rank in every skill I could possibly want in order to get that initial bonus before focusing on building important ones up came through pretty strong here. Untrained skills receive a -25 penalty, and that can be pretty crushing at low levels.

I left a few DPs unspent for minor stat boosts- mostly to bump up stats that were already right on the edge of the next modifier increase. It's that same kind of compulsion that you might get from staring at a bunch of odd-numbered ability scores in d20.

I decided not to go for any talents, beyond what was given to me by default. Talents, which as I mentioned earlier act a little like d20 feats, cost anywhere from 5 to 50 DPs depending on power. They can give you a new profession, expand your spellcasting abilities, give you a stacking bonus to a skill or set of skills that is a little more efficient per DP spent than if you bought ranks outright, or radically improve your survivability or utility in other ways.

Purchasing Equipment

The standard fantasy RPG arrangement of 1 gold piece = 10 silver pieces = 100 copper pieces is in place in HARP. Unlike D&D, copper and silver pieces are the most common coins you'll be dealing in day-to-day, so most prices are listed in cp or sp. Even so, new adventurers in Cyradon begin with 10+1d10 gold pieces. I rolled a pretty lucky 9, giving my Gryx almost maximum funds to play around with.

The first thing I wanted to buy was a Gryxian war fork. They adapted these babies from simple pitchforks used to tend to their mounts and herd animals. It's basically a seven foot-tall, bladed bident with a knob on the butt that can be used with either the Staves or the Pole Arms weapon skill. It can also be used to deal a medium amount of slashing, crushing, or puncture damage without penalty. It's so versatile as to be a little busted early on, and I want one. I'll also get a shortbow and quiver of 20 arrows, mostly for hunting.

Next is armor, which I'll be far more austere about. The heavier the armor, the harder and more expensive it is to cast any magic. A full suit of soft leather armor offers some protection without too much of a drain, and feels most appropriate for someone whose culture probably makes extensive use of animal hide clothing.

The single biggest purchase he'll make is a mount to bear him across the steppes and beyond. Since he's already kind of heavy (well over 200 lbs. before equipment) I opted for a medium horse with a carrying capacity of up to 500 lbs. It should be able to carry any extra gear or maybe an ailing companion, while sacrificing no speed and only a little maneuverability- and it's not like my Gryx is about to pick up horse archery.

He'll call his mare Tlakhi. I've decided the "tl" is a palatal click consonant (not that I'm any good at pronouncing those).

After that comes an assortment of doses of Cyradon's native herbs to treat minor injuries and ailments out on the road. Orudin for helping fractures mend faster, sarpal for frostbite, halin to improve rest from a full night's sleep, and seras tea as an impromptu healing potion for emergencies.

Final Touches

I've sort of been doing this last step the entire time by adding little bits of characterization here and there, but there's still more to take care of! The book tells us to consider things like appearance, attitude, and motivation, to make this character more than a lifeless pile of stats.

Also, he probably needs a name. I feel like maybe I should have led with that. Let's go with R'Shoq. The ' represents a glottal stop, and the 'q' is voiced from somewhere down by the tonsils.

R'Shoq only has three rows of head flanges, unlike the usual four or five. As a result he has a fuller head of hair, but he lacks the "washboard" forehead that many of his people find conventionally attractive.

This is what peak G'Shul performance looks like.

R'Shoq wears his dark brown hair in several braids to keep it back while he's chanting or hunched over a pestle. He is of average height, and not as muscular as most Gryx- not that that's saying much. His eyes are brown, in defiance of the common trope of magic users having fancy or unusual eye colors- but they do always look like he's just seen a ghost.

Speaking of ghosts, he talks to them semi-regularly. The Gryx's gods know what's up with the homeland and why they had to flee, but due to some meddling by a malicious third party, they can only communicate with their people in the most obtuse, vague prophesies. R'Shoq is following one of those prophesies right now, trying to weave together some of the disparate threads that have been left to his people on their journey west.

His tribe was one of the most mobile at first, stopping the least often and pushing the edges of their known world. As a result he acquired a smattering of knowledge about other cultures that they passed by- but only a surface-level understanding of them. As a result, he can be a bit awkward in his dealings with outsiders. While trying to be affable with strangers, he might be hundreds of miles off on a turn of phrase he thinks they might relate to.

Wrapping Up

I think this is the first d100 system I'd want to play more than a one-off with. I feel like I have more freedom with it than I did MERP, and more of an illusion of safety and control than Warhammer permits. I don't know how the numbers break down for mid-to-high-level play or whether anything starts to fall apart at that point, but I could see a low-level romp being crunchy and satisfying. The world is detailed, but also light enough on metaplot that neither me nor my nomad would feel totally lost during play.

Monday, October 25, 2021

New System, New Face: It's not Technically Cheating if the d20 System has a "True" in front of it

When I started this series, it was with the express purpose of exploring systems I've never really touched before, in light of my thus-far-brief lifetime of experience with d20 things. While I want to stick to that, I also kind of want to write about Blue Rose, the progenitor of the True20 system, a close but streamlined derivative by Green Ronin Publishing. And since this is my show, I'm going to exercise that agency my therapist keeps telling me about and do it anyway.

Romance and talking animals await!
Maybe not romance with the talking animals.
I dunno. The Kingdom of Aldis doesn't judge.

Game/Context

Blue Rose was first released in 2005. It was the debut of what would come to be named the True20 system, after its popularity caused Green Ronin to expand and republish the system for setting-agnostic use. Some of its DNA can be found in Green Ronin's current project, the 3d6-focused AGE (Adventure Game Engine) System.

Blue Rose is a Romantic Fantasy game, meaning it takes inspiration primarily from the literary genre of the same name. It is often said to have more in common with the stories of Mercedes Lackey than R. E. Howard, and in fact Lackey (alongside several other writers like Tamora Pierce) can be found in the core book's recommended reading section. Adventure and battle have their prominent place in Blue Rose, but complex interpersonal relationships, drama, and aforementioned romance are core elements.

The game is set in the world of Aldea, specifically in the Kingdom of Aldis. Aldis is unapologetically idealistic, though not without its own problems. The kingdom is ruled by a monarch who is selected by the Golden Hart, a divine being of Light that appears to select every heir, and has done so since it helped the world overthrow an empire of sorcerer-kings. The monarchy often runs down family lines, but can also transfer to another noble or to a commoner in this way. Nobles serve as part of a council of advisors to the crown, and may only become nobles after demonstrating their morality and purity of heart by being accepted by the eponymous Blue Rose scepter, a kind of divining rod of righteousness. And since it's all divine magic stemming from the Primordials, the gods of the world, it's hard to fake any of it.

It's an interesting mix of heavenly mandate and divine right of kings that is, once again, unapologetically idealistic.

Aldis is a pretty inclusive place, or at least more inclusive than many fantasy worlds of the mid-aughts were. Humans of a wide variety of ethnic backgrounds share the land with semiaquatic Sea People, psychic animal Rhydans (coming in dolphin, cat, wolf, and horse varieties), pseudo-half-elvish genocide survivor Vatas, and basically-orcs-except-fully-redeemed-and-also-conventionally-attractive Night People.

The book and the people within it make no fuss or assumptions about gender or sexual orientation, and creatively benevolent use of the Flesh Shaping sorcery found in-universe even allows for transgendered characters' bodies to more closely match who they are. People who take issue with any of the above are typically seen by Aldins as ignorant or bigoted.

This was apparently seen by some of the public as quite radical upon release, to the point that Google still offered the suggestion "blue rose rpg controversy" when I was researching the game recently. I want to say that's a funny artifact of a time since passed, but then again this is the same hobby where people made death threats over the existence of the Combat Wheelchair, so maybe I shouldn't be surprised.

Mechanics

Blue Rose's True20 system is essentially a streamlining of the more widely known d20 system. There are no other dice but the d20, which is used for all rolls including combat damage. The six classic ability scores are present, but their values are boiled down into modifiers between -5 and +5, so you never have to deal with calculating bonuses or having frustratingly useless odd numbered scores staring you right in the face until you finally burn an advancement just to make them nice and rounded.

There are only three classes or "roles" in True20- Adept, Expert, and Warrior. They approximate magic-users, skill specialists, and fighting types by themselves, but can be freely mixed and matched without multiclassing penalties. Aside from starting proficiencies, differing progression on roll bonuses, and role-locked feat lists, they don't have any class features, encouraging each player to build exactly what they want out of their character. It's an interesting take on a classed system that sometimes feels almost classless.

Skills are still present, in a form that presages later changes in many d20 systems. Instead of mucking about with assigning skill points every level, you are either trained or untrained in a skill, and you get a bonus to skill checks that scales with your level depending on if the skill is "known" or "favored". Favored and known skills receive your level +3, giving us the familiar 4 "ranks" at 1st level, while known but not favored skills received level +3 divided by 2. You can still make completely untrained skill checks, but your only bonus there is from the relevant ability score. Also, Diplomacy is still really really strong.

Feats are pretty much as featy as ever, except now you get them every level and they are your primary means of mechanical character growth. Skills, proficiencies, and combat tricks are gained through feats, as well as any and all magic abilities for adepts. There is a considerable range of power between feats, but I think there are fewer "newbie traps" than in D&D 3E, and the setting's less-than-total reliance on combat is always important to remember when developing a character.

And it's a good thing that Blue Rose doesn't demand huge amounts of combat, because it can get nasty. There are no hit points in True20- everyone has the same two-lane damage track for lethal and nonlethal damage. If you are struck by an attack, you must roll a Toughness check with a DC15 plus the attacker's damage bonus, which can include ability scores, weapon bonuses, and others. At 1st level an adventurer facing a random bandit with a short sword can easily be facing a steep DC18 roll to avoid damage.

When you do get damaged, you move down the damage track depending on how many increments of 5 you failed the Toughness save by. Each failed save gives a stacking penalty to future Toughness checks against that type of damage (lethal or nonlethal), and each level of the damage track offers a variety of other penalties to rolls. A few hits can debilitate you, and one botched roll that fails by 15 or more can leave you dying.

To escape the worst that bad dice rolls can throw at you, each PC (and any NPC with levels in a heroic role) has access to Conviction points. Conviction functions like a typical Luck or Hero Point mechanic, plus extra. You can spend a point to reroll and take the better of two die results, temporarily use a feat you don't possess (but can acquire normally), retain dodge bonus while surprised or flat-footed, take an extra action in a round, recover from damage or effects, or stabilize while dying. But characters have a set cap for Conviction that increases as they level, and they can only regain points passively at a slow rate (1/day) or by acting upon their Natures (described below).

One Sneaky Sphynx

To avoid some of combat's nastiness, I'm going to ignore the urge to make a Night Person earth elementalist and build someone a little more sneaky than usual. I will make a Rhy-cat expert who can easily prowl around while throwing up distractions and illusions and gleaning information with psychic powers. It's also going to be a wrinkly, hairless sphynx breed of Rhy-cat, because the last thing you want on a covert operation is for your team member's allergies to act up, or for the target to discover you thanks to a hairball. And besides, is there anything more demoralizing to the enemy than seeing this thing ambush them?

It can smell what you did last summer.

But first come ability scores.

Because they've been boiled down into modifiers, you don't need any point-buy system. The book just gives you 6 points to distribute among 6 attributes, with a starting max of +3 in each. Rhydans only get 4 points because of their other abilities. I decide on Strength -1, Dexterity +1, Constitution +1, Intelligence +1, Wisdom +1, Charisma +1. With Rhy-cat racial stats added on, that's +0/+3/+2/+1/+1/+1. I could have taken more negative modifiers and specialized further, but I don't enjoy having negative stat modifiers- playing a well-rounded individual without massive objective faults is one of the highs of escapist fantasy.

Since I've already picked Expert as this psykit's role, I next have to choose favored skills, known skills, and starting feats. I will make every choice I can while building, instead if just choosing one of the suggested starting Paths that get presented in the core book and then expanded as full 20-level builds in the Blue Rose Companion.

Remember when third-party d20 books would include "guides" to character types from their fluff that amounted to "just take this class or mix it 50/50 with this other class and that's pretty much it"? Don't get me wrong, I still like the novelty and own a lot of those, especially from the Conan d20 line, but looking back it feels like padding the catalogue.

Anyway.

Skills

Experts choose 12 skills plus one Crafting as their favored skills. Rhydans get a normally crippling -20 penalty to skills that require fine digital manipulation like sleight of hand, craft, disable device, etc. But with an arcanum to conjure a pair of arcane hands to do the manipulating for you, that penalty can get circumvented in favor of a mere -2, allowing them to still be valid choices for an animal adventurer.

In light of this, my Rhy-cat favors Acrobatics, Bluff, X, Concentration, Craft ( ), Disable Device, Escape Artist, Jump, Knowledge (Local), X, Search, Sense Motive, and Sleight of Hand. They also gain Climb, Notice, Sneak, and Survival thanks to their species and background.

Known skills are 6+Int to start off. I'll select Acrobatics, Climb, Disable Device, Escape Artist, Notice, Search, and Sneak. Rhy-cat bonuses grant +8 to Climb/Jump and +4 to Sneak, making our wrinkly friend a good prowler on tree limbs or on rooftops. I'm trying real hard not to make any cat burglar puns here.

Feats

Next come starting feats.

Rhydans receive Psychic Talent for free and Experts receive Armor Training (light), as well as my choice of 3 others. The armor training is a bit wasted on my cat at the moment, since Rhydans need specially fitted armor that raises the cost by +10 and my cat starts with 0 Wealth (more on that mechanic later).

I am dismayed that Rhy-cat natural claws and bites don't count as light weapons, or Weapon Finesse would be my first feat to get more out of my +3 Dex in combat. Alas they're not, so we'll keep going stealthy and avoidant with our feats. Arcane Training (Illusion & Sleep) will help, as will Shaping Talent (Manipulate Object) and Trapfinding.

Equipment

Now to figure what, if anything, my cat has in their possession. To do that, we're gonna have to consult the Wealth rules.

Instead of measuring every price, reward, or value in exact gold piece amounts, everything is given an abstract Wealth Score or Wealth DC. Wealth Score is a character's ability to buy things, represented by a modifier that sits at +0 minimum, but can increase infinitely, with +31 being extremely, lavishly rich. Whenever you want to purchase something for your character, you must roll a Wealth Check against the DC or Cost of the desired purchase.

You can Take 10 or 20 on the check with extra time spent shopping, and if your score naturally equals or exceeds an item's cost, you can get it for free. Succeeding on a check to buy a very expensive item, or one whose cost is higher than your modifier reduces your wealth by X amount, so you will eventually burn through your cash, even if the system seems more generous or more luck-based than gold and WBL in D&D.

Most characters start with +5 Wealth, but my cat starts at +0 since Rhydans don't have a lot of use for humanoid tools or comforts. Even so, a +0 doesn't disqualify you from affording anything- you can still roll for anything with a cost of 9 or lower, and you can't ever dip below +0.

Rhydan body shape means the cheapest armor my cat could wear costs 16, so that's not happening until later. Weapons are also useless, though I am somewhat surprised there are no special Rhydan weapon attachments like metal claws or hoof spikes or what have you. This leaves my sphynx free to focus on the little things... or it would have allowed them to focus on the little things, had I not rolled a Nat 1 trying to purchase a fricking backpack in which to hold anything.

You are allowed to retry wealth checks, but not before spending X hours shopping, which I can't really do during character creation. That would feel more than a little cheap- why not then just reroll until I get everything I want from an arbitrarily long shopping spree at some point in the nebulous Before Time?

Fortunately a sack costs 0, and I got a 9 on the DC 2 belt pouch check, so my cat will just carry one around in their mouth between missions and rely on a utility belt otherwise. Manipulate Object allows them to interact with all of their items as if they had humanoid hands, so they can benefit from small tools like a waterskin, flint and steel, paper for writing down notes (they can't physically speak, but presumably they are still literate in their known languages), and a whetstone to keep the claws sharp.

Characteristics

The last major part of character generation is one we're all familiar with by now- all the little questions that help round your character out as a person with thoughts and feelings. The standard name, gender, age, appearance, alignment, and personality apply, along with Blue rose's addition of romantic inclination and/or status. Tajid, for their part, is an unfathomable wrinkle who has no need for such things- or so they think.

More unique to the game are a hero's Calling and Natures.

Everyone gets a Calling, which is their primary motivation to adventure, and in life in general. They are selected by way of picking a Major Arcana card from a deck of the Royal Road, which just so happens to be functionally identical to the tarot deck in our world. Since I don't own a tarot deck and it's weird to roll a d22 for the list of choices, I'll just pick The Moon- it represents the learning of secrets, which fits well with their whole M.O. as long as they have the sense to avoid the wrong kinds of secrets. Something about curiosity and cats.

Alignment is a simple three-point axis that is like but decidedly unlike the Lawful/Neutral/Chaotic axis of old. Everyone is made of varying degrees of Light, Shadow, and Twilight, and all it takes for one to become dominant is to make a decisive change of heart- every hero has a threat of darkness and cynicism in them, every villain a spark of hope, etcetera and so on.

Light is the belief in community (in any form, not just what one might consider "civilization", and without an emphasis on law & order), harmonious coexistence, and promoting the general good for all. Shadow is petty and selfish at its core, sometimes entertaining the notion of cooperation or moral justification, but only so far as it serves one's own interest. Twilight is anyone in between the two extremes, whether that takes the form of careful balance between the two natures or fluctuating back and forth between them to a certain degree.

Tajiid is still figuring things out, so we'll go with Twilight.

Natures are specific manifestations of a character's Light and Shadow tendencies that act as positive and negative character motivators, respectively. They also act as extrinsic roleplay encouragement, thanks to their role in regaining Conviction points. When a character acts on their natures to regain Conviction, they really gotta sell it, live up to their nature, and live with their consequences.

There are 56 natures for each card in the deck, with each nature being two takes on a particular quality- sometimes they are simple inverses like generous vs greedy, but others are more subtle/subjective distinctions of a single idea like enthusiastic vs overzealous, or resourceful vs sneaky.

For these I will randomly roll just to see what I get. 27 on my Light nature gives me Devoted, and 35 on Shadow is Reckless. I can work with this. Tajiid is a workaholic as mentioned before, and this reflects their devotion to their goal. They prowl, spy, and occasionally steal in the interest of gathering intelligence and keeping Aldea and peoples beyond it safe. But they can go overboard at times, recklessly pursuing something or someone beyond their means to safely or stealthily handle.

With these finishing touches in place, our Rhy is finished.

Going Forward

Of course we're not done at level 1, especially not in a system that allows one to fully build out their concept up to the max level. I won't be going as far as making multiple sheets at different levels because strangely enough I never enjoyed that part of the process much, but I will give growth examples.

Only three ability increases come to you over the course of leveling, at 6th, 12th, and 18th. One will definitely be devoted to Dexterity, likely two so that it reaches the +5 max. The other might go into Constitution, or even Strength just because it looks sad sitting there at 0.

You gain a feat every level in True20, so they pile up fast. Early on, Tajiid will take a Skill Training or two to flesh out their array of known favored skills. Skills requiring training to use at all will be definite picks, but not right away. Later on in the lower mid-levels Brew Elixir gives us some use for the required Craft skill choice made during creation, though they aren't pure buffs like most potions in D&D- many Blue Rose elixirs hit you with levels of fatigue after their duration is finished, and if you ran yourself ragged during that time you might take lethal damage.

Arcana will be the bulk of Tajiid's feat choices, I feel. There are several powers that would benefit a spy like Mind Reading to detect surface-level thoughts. Our wrinkle will need to be careful not only for their targets but for themself if they ever want to try reading deeper thoughts using Mind Probe, however. Any magic that is overtly harmful, invasive, or violates an individual's body or free will is Sorcery, which risks Corruption points. A situation may present itself where it seems necessary, but executing on it all depends on how dim their Twilight becomes.

As Tajiid adventures with or without companions, they'll begin to yearn for a pack of their own, and to appreciate the responsibility of caring for and nurturing the future. They'll learn the Familiar feat to gain a small, magical cat friend as a sort of nonstandard adoption, and they will befriend the mundane strays of Aldis with judicious use of one or two Animism arcana. No street corner or alleyway will be without eyes and ears. Weavers of Shadow beware.

Presumably the animal vocalizations every Rhydan makes will be enough for Tajiid to "speak" to other cats without magic, so either Handle Animal or Diplomacy might work instead, depending on your interpretation of things.

Someday, still a speck on the horizon, Tajiid will be able to afford better gear. Maybe even one of those absurdly priced Rhydan-fitted suits of armor. A set of masterwork studded leather armor adds +13 to the price for a whopping DC of 25 however, so it will be a while and more than a few odd jobs before they can wriggle their folds into a suit like someone trying to stuff a gallon of prunes into an old boot.

Thursday, August 5, 2021

New System, New Face: Bumbling through Rolemaster's Geeky Little Sibling, Middle-Earth Role-Play

It finally occurred to me that I should
head these posts with an image of the
actual game.


Ye gods, I miss Warhammer- and not for the setting.

At least in WFRP I felt some intuitive grasp of the mechanics as I worked through making characters.

Here, I've written an entire post and I still don't know what to do for Middle-Earth Role-Play.

Fortunately its initials perfectly match the noise that flaps out of my mouth when my eyes glaze over at the fact that over half of this 270-page tome is made up of appendices needed to explain each part of the first half:

MERP!

Alright, that's my last awful joke for the moment. Let's dig in, shall we?

Game/Context/More Rambling

MERP was yet another d100 skills-based fantasy game spawned by the 80s, with the notable distinction of being licensed to use the world of Lord of the Rings as its setting. There have been several other Tolkien Enterprises-licensed TTRPGs over the past four decades, including Cubicle 7's current work on Adventures in Middle-Earth, but MERP was the first of the bunch, published by Iron Crown Enterprises in 1982 and updated with a second edition in 1993.

MERP runs on an apparently simplified/streamlined hack of the Rolemaster system, also designed by the people from I.C.E. Rolemaster is chunky. It's crunchy. It places emphasis on granular, lethal combat where weapon and armor types interact differently, crits and fumbles have pages of tables, and you can earn XP per injury taken. It's a weird thing to pair with LotR in terms of execution and tone.

Of course you don't need a perfect system to be able to tell the story you want, since story flows from the storytellers involved rather than the mechanics they're using, but it certainly seems more difficult to do when the two parts are tugging in opposite directions.

Characters progress via a leveling and class system unlike the other games I've looked at so far here. There are six classes or "professions" that are roughly analogous to both AD&D character classes and to the roles embodied by many of the famous characters from LotR- warrior, ranger, scout, bard, animist, and mage, arranged in descending order of combat ability and ascending order of spellcasting ability, though pretty much anyone can conjure a trick or swing a stick if direly needed.

Yes, magic is a thing PCs can acquire in this game. It's rarely anything as flashy as the few attack or utility spells Gandalf throws out there in the books, and there are mechanisms in place to restrain both rampant spellcasting and the intent behind it if you want to remain a non-corrupted protagonist. Different spell schools or "ways" are highly specialized and limited by class. There's one way dedicated to walking or running on different surfaces, and another strictly dealing with staunching blood loss. But limitations aside, it is still conspicuous supernatural power learned and wielded by mortals (and elves) that is not conflated with sorcery originating from darkness, as Tolkien tended to treat it.

Tolkien hated describing things as "magic", and anything that looked that way from the outside was generally explainable as being just really high skill, craftsmanship, or a gifted blessing from a higher power of some sort. In my experience Tolkien purists dislike it when games make that jump to accessible magic, but many more people enjoy it because using magic is something people commonly find appealing in fantasy. Despite how often I prattle on about the universe or hyperlink to Tolkien Gateway like an appeal to authority, I am decidedly not a purist, so I have no qualms with the stylistic choice.

The default setting for MERP is, well, Middle-Earth, but not in any time period extensively touched upon by the books. Most of the modules take place a few years after the Great Plague of T.A. 1635, or year 1635 of the Third Age for those of you who at least occasionally see the light of day. The War of the Ring isn't for another 1,400 years in this era, and the Shire is a brand new community, founded barely four decades ago.

It's a time when the profound emptiness of the lands of Middle-Earth that we see in the trilogy has just truly begun, thanks in part to that aforementioned plague that killed hundreds of thousands of people. The population will only dwindle further from here, until barely any towns or cities exist for Sauron to try and take in a millennium-and-a-half. Salty Dan made an amusing observation from atop his Throne a little while ago about how weak and unimpressive this makes Sauron and how wonky it makes Tolkien's sense of scale and history when you take any time to think about it, but I'm getting ahead of myself now.

For now, it's the last hurrah of party-based adventuring in Middle-Earth. Let's populate it with a fresh new face or two.

So. Many. Tables.

After slogging through the first 77 pages of the MERP rulebook, you finally come to Part V: Designing A Character. That should give you an idea of how dense the rules are, simplified ruleset or no. The ten steps of character generation, as given by the book are:

  1. Decide in general what type of character to play.*
  2. Roll and assign your character's stats.*
  3. Choose a race for your character.*
  4. Choose a profession for your character.*
  5. Determine role traits and background.
  6. Develop your character's adolescence skills.
  7. Develop your character's apprenticeship skills.
  8. Outfit your character.
  9. Total your character's penalties and bonuses.
  10. Develop a persona for your character.
The asterisks mean these steps are all interrelated with one another.

As I went through each step, it ended up being simpler or much less significant than it was presented above or throughout the rest of the book, and the whole list could easily be reordered and condensed into half the above steps. That long-windedness throughout the book is a thing I think I can attribute to it being a crunchy '80s RPG- short, efficient instructions weren't the norm yet, and my mindset needs time to readjust to the delivery of information.

And here I thought I was an expert on rambling, inefficient writing. Oh well.

Step 1 also knocks out steps 3, 4, and 10 in my case. I want to make a female dwarf scout of the Blacklocks clan who's had one hell of a trek west into Endor- a refugee turned survivor, far from her ancestral home in the Orocarni.

I do want to give a shout-out to the sheer number of cultures characters can come from in MERP. Every variety of elf is available, plus dwarves and hobbits, as well as every human culture from Dunlendings to Easterlings to the people of Far Harad- even the Variags of Khand, those one-line wonders from the Battle of Pelennor Fields, get fleshed out with licensed fanfiction into a playable background. And that's not even counting the optional orcs, and trolls of all groups!

I really appreciate this. If I ever get back to my On the Trail of the Blue Wizards campaign idea about peoples of "darkness" finding heroism, I will definitely use much of the fluff of MERP's culture entries.

Back to our girl, though.

Her name is Grid, derived from the Old Norse name Gríðr, which could mean vehemence or peace depending. I figured that would be appropriate for a Tolkien dwarf when virtually all of their names are Norse in origin, but I also thought it would be grimly amusing if the way the name was decided on was because her workaholic architect dad couldn't be bothered to look up from his workbench when she was born, and he just jammed on the first thing his eyes fell upon- the blueprint grid.

Next comes rolling the 7 stats; Strength, Agility, Constitution, Intelligence, Intuition, Presence, and also Appearance- yes, this game shows its considerable age by having an objective physical hotness stat, and yes the higher your stat is, the better your initial reactions from people are.

I wanted to say that also feels tonally inconsistent with the setting because initially deceiving appearances and "foul seeming fair" are recurring tropes in Tolkien, but then I thought about how 90% of the time the other Tolkienian trope of exterior matching the interior results in goodness being innately beautiful and evil being visibly ugly, so I guess a mechanical beauty stat is only inappropriate for the setting if the character is a total monster without a shred of magical glamour to their high beauty score, or the utterly heroic character is conventionally unattractive- and I don't mean just being a little scruffy and unbathed like Aragorn at the Prancing Pony. But I digress again.

For each stat you roll d100 and as long as it's a 20 or higher, you're keeping it. 10-24 gives a -5 penalty, 25-74 is a flat 0, 75-89 is a +5, and the ever-narrowing ranges above that eventually top out at a +25 from rolling a perfect 100, with 101 (+30) and 102+ (+35) being theoretical but hard to achieve. These modifiers are used for pretty much all rolls, skills and combat maneuvers included.

On my first roll I managed to smash it out of the park with a 99. Not so much when the second came up 23. Next came 88, 87, 66, and 77. I decided my dwarf lass would have the array 99 Strength, 23 Agility, 66 Constitution, 77 Intelligence, 87 Intuition, and 88 Presence. By itself this would give her the mods +20/-5/+0/+5/+5/+5, but thanks to a rule allowing you to raise your profession's primary stat to 90 if it's lower, my scout can raise her Agility up to an even 90 to turn that -5 into a +10.

All of this is before cultural modifiers, of course. Dwarvish stoutness and gruffness means that Strength gets a further +5 to the mod, Agility takes a -5 hit, Constitution gets a massive +15, and both Intuition and Presence take -5. Thus, our mod array looks like +20/+5/+15/+5/+0/+0 for the moment, and normally that would be the final tally.

Ah, but next we have Background traits...

Childhood? There's a table for that. Awkward teens? Table for that. Xenophobia? Table for that!

Background options are the specific bonuses available through your character's culture, including skill ranks, extra stat buffs on top of the above, randomly rolled special abilities, access to certain schools or "laws" of magic, and even starting with magic items in one's possession.

Since my dwarf ain't magic and has been roughing it a couple hundred miles now, I declined both magic and magic items. Maybe she still has a really nice hair ornament in her beard, but it's quite mundane. I decided to go all in on stat boosts, since you can't purchase those after character creation. The actual numbers we rolled for stats become almost worthless after creation outside of some dramatic occurrences or magic, after all- it's all about those incremental modifiers. You get 4 background options, so I put them into +2 to Strength and then three iterations of +1 Agility/Intuition/Presence, mostly just to raise the latter two up to a +10 base bonus.

Her almost!final stat array becomes +35/+5/+15/+5/+5/+5. Sure, the scout is meant to be about stealth and, if need be, ambush and thievery, but that doesn't mean she can't also be an absolute beast of a unit too. Besides, she needs every edge she can get in this shallow, superficial world after getting an Appearance of 32, bumped slightly by her Presence modifier to 37.

Role Traits are a fancy way of dressing up stuff like personality type, character motivation, and moral alignment. Instead of giving a few examples as a guide to coming to one's own conclusion for their character, you're instead encouraged to pick from the given lists in order to fill out a prescribed part of your character sheet.

Personality is exemplified by a long list of poles arranged in opposition to one another, like Meek vs. Proud or Optimistic vs. Cynical. It seems you can pick several if you wish, as long as they don't directly oppose one another.

Motivation is why your character adventures at all. A surprising number of the 20 motivations are either self-interested like wealth accumulation or doing it for fun, or negative motivations like hatred, fear, or a desire to destroy X. X can be expected targets like Darkness or specifically Sauron's forces, individuals you have a vendetta against, or some more problematic choices like entire countries, cultures, or species. Earlier on in the book, playing an orc or troll is explicitly discouraged, but it seems that choice wasn't intended to limit a PC's capacity to be evil.

Alignment is weird. It's another collection of supposedly opposed traits, of which Good vs. Evil is only one, but the way all of the other dichotomies are arranged underneath them seems to imply which are also kind of good or bad without making it clear. The book then proceeds to bring in real-life examples that further date it in a way I found damn uncomfortable.

As if it needed spelling out, Dear Burrowers,
real life religious communities are not
diametrically opposed to one another.
Also I don't think we use "Moslem" anymore.

Grid's just gonna be Neutral for now.

Next come adolescence and apprenticeship skills, which are similar to background options except they're unique to your character's growth and development as a person prior to taking up adventuring. Both of these steps have a full page of tables dedicated to them too, because when you merp, you merp hard.

Being a dwarf means Grid's childhood trained her 1 rank in Unarmored Movement & Maneuvers, 1 in Rigid Leather Armor, 3 in Chain, 4 in One-Handed Concussive Weapons, 1 Thrown, 1 Climb, 1 Pick Lock, 1 Disarm Trap, 2 Perception, 3 Body Development, and 3% chance of learning a free spell list- I rolled a 77 on that, so that's a hard and fast no. Grid also gains 4 extra ranks to spend on languages- probably evenly divided between a smattering of some Elvish and nearby Easterling dialects.

Apprenticeship implies she was formally instructed by a master scout, but fortunately there isn't any sort of table where you roll the master's effectiveness as a teacher to affect how much your character learned during their apprenticeship or some such- though I wouldn't be surprised if that's a thing in true Rolemaster. Instead, we'll just say Grid picked up her extra skill ranks by sneaking around the dwarf hold, observing others, and reading or practicing in her weirdly spacious subterranean bedroom.

With all of this sorted out, or nearly so, we finally begin to get a clearer picture of Grid- by which I mean I frantically make stuff up to accommodate what the dice tell me.

Grid spent most of her life indoors, since only about 1/3rd of dwarves are female and they tend to be cloistered as a result. She is also quiet and reserved among outsiders out of unfamiliarity. She was tacked onto a delegation sent west by the Blacklocks because her father no longer believed the house's home was safe for her, what with all the troubles brewing in the east. The delegation dwindled until only Grid remains.

She has been kept alive this long by her adaptiveness, and her ability to put into practice the wide range of topics she read about while utterly bored back home. She wishes to bring aid to her people, but she might leave out the part of the mission where she was to be handed over for safekeeping. Being constantly misgendered by non-dwarves was and still is a confusing annoyance, but if it allows her to travel freely without being badgered by overprotective menfolk, she will allow it to continue- or perhaps even consciously try to 'pass' if the situation requires it.

Wrapping Up.

The last major step of character generation that isn't just review is Outfitting. After spending minutes flipping back and forth between the Outfitting page where limits and stipulations are set in place, and the Dwarf page (147) where the actual list of stuff offered, and the Equipment table on 255 where the weights are offered, I was finally done with Grid.

For some reason MERP dwarves don't have any starting ranks in one-handed edged weapons so they can effectively use axes, one of their most culturally important weapons. But Grid has likely just scavenged whatever gear she can from her dead traveling companions, so I doubt she'll turn down a shortbow and club that happen to be handy. Weirdly enough, she's way more graceful in mail armor than leather, so she gets a set of chain. She gets a set of clothing, probably weathered and travel-stained, plus some personal effects like a grooming kit- the beard needs to stay looking good, regardless of circumstances.

She also gets 2 gold pieces to spend on other gear, but since there's an entire section on economics in Middle-Earth and there are five currency subdivisions that fluctuate in value depending on time in the Third Age, I'm just going to treat the basic utilities as met. Grid is also going to have a donkey saved from the last cart of the ill-fated expedition so that she can carry most of her things without being subjected to a weirdly discriminatory encumbrance rule.

Carrying limits are determined by height in this system, with strength serving to offset some of the penalties for going over the limit. While height varies quite a bit between species and cultures, women are consistently one height class shorter than their male counterparts, so female PCs can carry less across the board. Shockingly enough there're no random table for height and weight rolling, so the gender averages given in each species' writeup are pretty much what you're stuck with.

There is a rule meant to offset this, giving female characters a +3% to either Agility or Constitution (I ended up going with Agility), but it's buried deep in the optional materials section toward the back of the book, sandwiched right in between Martial Arts in Middle-Earth, and a percentile table for how a character's blood proximity to the royal family of Númenor affects their ability to use Athelas as a healing herb.

No, I am not making this up.

I know Aragorn's prowess in the Houses
of Healing was ambiguously supernatural,
but surely they didn't mean this.

The end result of this whole experiment was not what I was expecting, but then again I went into this whole thing not knowing what to expect. I hope I haven't (completely) trashed MERP for anyone out there, because it does seem to be a common consensus that character creation is the first boss of the game- once you get around to the actual playing part, it becomes much smoother, simpler, and more fun.

For those who would want to play without generating at all, I have very good news that the book comes with 16 premade characters with level-up tracks included.

Then again, if any old LotR game by I.C.E. is what you're interested in, consider trying LoR, their later product that was actually designed as a simplified introduction to MERP. The designers recognized at some point that their game was too daunting for beginners, but instead of finding a rules solution in the system itself, they wrote an entire transitionary game designed to be played for a few weeks or months before moving on to the big leagues of the d100.

LoR had its own following, surprisingly, and at least one fan wrote an expanded homebrew ruleset for it called the Middle-Earth Adventure Game. MEAG is set somewhere in between LoR and MERP in complexity, but it's packaged in a mercifully svelte 30-page PDF that you can download for free on the website, which was last updated back in 2010. Yes, it has been a while, but at least it was in this millennium.